1. It took us a while to venture over from Four Winds to try Heston’s. Best snap decision imaginable. Aside from the appearance which is classic for a midwestern supper club, trom the start the courtesy and friendliness of the staff from front of house to bar to table was first rate. Bar staff makes a proper martini.
2. The best hands in the house are crafting tasty deli and restaurant dishes at Timbers Fast Food & Deli at Four Winds New Buffalo. You’ll find all your fast food favorites including jumbo hot dogs, crisp salads, burgers and more: Gourmet jumbo hot dogs and deluxe burgers.

Best Dining in New Buffalo, Berrien County: See 6,158 Tripadvisor traveller reviews of 36 New Buffalo restaurants and search by cuisine, price, location, and more. WEDNESDAYS AT FOUR WINDS NEW BUFFALO, HARTFORD & DOWAGIAC. Get 25% Off at Timbers and Kankakee Grille at Four Winds New Buffalo; Earn 100 W♣ Points at Four Winds New Buffalo, Dowagiac or Hartford, then visit a kiosk between 8am - 10pm Eastern to receive $10 in Instant Credit/Free Slot Play; See W♣ or Guest Services for complete details.

Where to eat in New Buffalo Michigan?
Restaurants, Bars, Grills and Eateries

Restaurants At Four Winds Casino New Buffalo Michigan Hotels

There are COVID-19 Restrictions in place for restaurants and bars – Outdoor dining and take-out only. Call ahead to see if an establishment is open for business during the State-mandated safety precautions (currently set @ Nov 18 – Dec 9, 2020).

Besides the household names commonly associated with a quick meal like Subway and McDonald’s, New Buffalo, Michigan has some unique independent restaurants that will appeal just about everybody.

• Bentwood Tavern
  Marina Grand Resort
  600 W. Water St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  

• Beer Church Brewing Co.
  24 S Whittaker St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117-1820
  (219) 771-0635

• Brewsters Italian Cafe
  Wood-fired Pizza, Pasta, Salads, & Deli
  11 W. Merchant Street
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-3005

Restaurants At Four Winds Casino New Buffalo Michigan Restaurants

• Casey’s Bar & Grill
  American Cuisine – late night dining
  136 N. Whittaker Street
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-6400

• Copper Rock Steakhouse
  Four Winds Casino Resort
  11113 Wilson Rd
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  

• David’s Delicatessen
  30 N. Whittaker St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-7177

• Dinner’s Ready…Set…Go!
  424 E. Buffalo St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-1702

• Dooley’s Lake House Pub
  310 West Buffalo St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-2247

• El Rancho Grande
  310 E. Buffalo Street
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-9600

• Four Winds Casino Buffet
  Four Winds Casino Resort
  11111 Wilson Rd.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (866) 494-6371

• Fresco
  108 North Whittaker St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 612-4000

• Ghost Isle Brewery
  17684 U.S. 12
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-9069

• I CAN Café
  910 W Buffalo St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-9957

• Jackie’s Cafe
  801 W. Buffalo St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-1800

• Kankakee Grille
  Four Winds Casino Resort
  11111 Wilson Rd.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  1-866-494-6371

• Luisa’s Cafe
  13698 Red Arrow Hwy
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-9037

• McDonalds
  18881 La Porte Rd.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-1924

• Nancy’s
  Walk-up treats & Hot Dogs
  142 N Whittaker St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-4240

• New Buffalo Beach Club
  Milkshakes, Fries, Sandwiches, Wraps and more
  @ the Public Beach
  New Buffalo, MI 49117

• Oinks Dutch Treat
  Ice cream & atmosphere!
  227 W Buffalo St (across from City Hall)
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-3535

• Pizza Hut/Wings Street
  700 E. Buffalo St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-6900

• Redamak’s
  Popular Seasonal Hangout – Burgers
  616 East Buffalo St
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-4522

• Roma Pizza
  17600 Red Arrow Hwy
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-3698

• Rios Mexican Food
  901 W Buffalo St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-8011

• Rosie’s Restaurant
  American cuisine
  128 North Whittaker St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-4382

• Sage Bistro
  9 South Barton St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-9542

• Skip’s Restaurant & Catering
  Prime Rib & steaks
  16710 Lakeshore Road
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  Shuttle Bus Available
  (269) 469-3330

• Song Asian Cuisine
  301 W. Buffalo St (US-12)
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 586-3699

• Stray Dog Bar & Grill
  Breakfast/Brunch, Late Night
  245 North Whittaker Street
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-2727

• Terrace Cafe & Lounge
  at the Harbor Grand
  111 West Water Street
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  

• Timbers Fast Food & Deli
  Four Winds Casino Resort
  11111 Wilson Rd.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (866) 494-6371

• Villa Nova Pizzeria
  134 W. Buffalo St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-0200

• White Birch Market
  Four Winds Casino Resort
  11113 Wilson Rd
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
• Whittaker Woods
  12578 Wilson Rd
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 469-3400
• Zoe’s Gourmet
  910 W Buffalo St.
  New Buffalo, MI 49117
  (269) 586-0200